WCET DISCUSSION FORUM: Policies Around Using AI For Grading by Senior Instructional Designer Steve Covello at University of New Hampshire
WCET DISCUSSION FORUM: Policies Around Using AI For Grading by Senior Instructional Designer Steve Covello at University of New Hampshire avatar

What policies or guidelines on using AI are in place at your institution for grading student work by the faculty? Specifically:

  1. Do you have policies about using AI to grade student work?
  2. If your institution doesn’t allow AI grading.
  3. If there are types of grading where it may be ok, such as grammar and spelling, but not for actual comments.
  4. Whether or not some people may believe some percentage of AI-written comments is ok when used with faculty comments.

GPT, short for Generative Pre-trained Transformer, is a series of advanced AI models created by OpenAI, designed to produce human-like text and content with remarkable fluency and coherence. If you are not familiar with a GPT, it is a specialized ChatGPT AI tool I created in my account that has been “infused” with specifications to look for certain things. The instructions include the assignment description, a list of typical feedback, an exemplary paper to use as a reference, and instructions not to allow re-writing through the GPT.

In the online courses that I teach, I do not use AI to grade student’s work, but I provide them with an AI-based GPT that they can use to “pre-flight” their draft papers before they submit them. The GPT does not grade their work – it is designed to indicate to students where their work needs attention, such as fulfilling the assignment requirements and covering all the topics.

Students are not required to use the Pre-Flight Evaluators, and I have provided a separate page that explains what the GPT does and what the results mean/don’t mean. The goal is to provide “feedback before feedback” so that it also reduces remediation effort by the instructor.

I have attached an anonymized sample paper for you to try it yourself. Go to my Pre-Flight GPT, upload it, and review the results. AI has the potential to enhance feedback in various ways, though it remains in an experimental stage.

 Attachments

COM 680 Sample 4.docx 33.35 kB

COM 680 Option 1 Pre-flight Evaluator

Steve Covello

Senior Instructional Designer

Senior Adjunct Online Faculty

University of New Hampshire

(603) 513-1346

steve.covello@unh.edu

cps.unh.edu/online

D2L April 2025 Updates
D2L April 2025 Updates avatar

D2L April Updates

Assignments and Discussions – Bulk feedback for instructors | New

This feature enables instructors to provide bulk feedback to learners directly within the Assignments and Discussions submission pages, enhancing efficiency and user experience.

Key capabilities:

  • Add and save bulk feedback as a draft if none exists.
  • Update existing drafts or published evaluations for multiple learners simultaneously.
  • Apply feedback to selected learners using Add Feedback or to all learners using Add Feedback to All.
  • Display a warning message when saving an empty Feedback dialog as bulk feedback, as this action overwrites existing drafts or published evaluations.
Figure: Add Feedback to All button in Assignment Submissions area
Figure: Add Feedback to All button in discussion assessment area

Quizzes – New Quiz Evaluation Experience transitioning to default, with opt-out until July 2025 | Updated

With last month’s update to the type of questions available in the New Quiz Evaluation Experience, content parity now exists between the two forms. Most instructors are already using the New Quiz Evaluation Experience, but the option to opt-out of the New Quiz Evaluation Experience will being going away during our July 2025 update.

Brightspace Training Resources | Reminder

Following our Brightspace Training webinar series, all past recordings and information from the trainings are accessible via the Discover tool from the Brightspace homepage where instructors can now self-enroll in the course. This course is purely for the archival of webinar training content but it has been opened for Instructor view!

Figure: Discover link on the homepage navbar and the Brightspace Training Resources course

Instructor Guided Training | Reminder

If you have not done so already, please feel free to access our D2L guided instructor training course by clicking the link with the D2L moose on your homepage. At first this training looks barren with only a few items, but as you complete each module a new one will open up! This training goes through the basics of D2L all the way through more advanced tools and is available to all instructors of the college. You will also be entered to win some D2L branded prizes such as a Morris the Moose plushie, travel pillows, and tumbler cups!

Figure: The instructor guided training link.

Free Virtual Webinar: Supporting Student Success in Online Courses: Insights from Students and Faculty Thursday April 3rd, 2025 from 3:00 pm – 4:00 pm ET
Free Virtual Webinar: Supporting Student Success in Online Courses: Insights from Students and Faculty Thursday April 3rd, 2025 from 3:00 pm – 4:00 pm ET avatar

How can online college courses better support student motivation, engagement, and help-seeking behaviors?

Join the Postsecondary Teaching with Technology Collaborative for a public webinar where we explore student experiences in online courses and new evidence-based strategies to address challenges students encounter in online formats.

Panelists, including researchers, students, and faculty, will share and reflect on key findings on the role that self-directed learning (SDL) can play in promoting student success in online courses.

The webinar will feature findings from interviews with students enrolled in online courses at eight colleges and universities, an introduction to a set of practical strategies that instructors can implement to enhance student support in online learning environments, and a panel discussion featuring community college students.

Presenters

  • Susan Bickerstaff, Senior Research Associate, Community College Research Center
  • Akilah Thompson, Senior Research Assistant, Community College Research Center
  • Hannah Cheever, Senior Education Researcher, SRI
  • Candace Walker, Associate Professor, Palm Beach State College
  • Mason Gallagher, Sophomore, Wake Technical Community College
  • Emily Vershay, Sophomore, Wake Technical Community College

Related Resources

Registration link: https://sri.zoomgov.com/webinar/register/WN_69RVvkolSFGfVg0GyW_3Yg#/registration

D2L March 2025 Updates
D2L March 2025 Updates avatar

D2L March Updates

Brightspace Training Resources | New

Following our Brightspace Training webinar series, all past recordings and information from the trainings are accessible via the Discover tool from the Brightspace homepage where instructors can now self-enroll in the course. This course is purely for the archival of webinar training content but it has been opened for Instructor view!

Figure: Discover link on the homepage navbar and the Brightspace Training Resources course

Quizzes – Additional question types in new quiz evaluation experience | Updated

The new quiz evaluation experience, introduced in September 2024, initially supported a subset of question types, including Multiple ChoiceWritten ResponseTrue or FalseShort AnswerFill in the Blank, and Multi-Select. It also allowed Question Pools containing these question types.

To fully support the new quiz evaluation experience, this release expands support to include the following additional quiz question types:

  • Arithmetic
  • Matching
  • Ordering
  • Multi Short Answer
  • Significant Figures

Rubrics – Added Rubric Level Range Visual | New

This release introduces rubric level ranges in rubric headings, improving clarity for instructors and students:

  • Instructors can now see rubric level ranges while creating and evaluating rubrics, except for holistic rubrics and non-sequential custom points.
  • students can view rubric level ranges in assessments, ensuring a clear understanding of point distributions.

Previously, instructors had to manually explain rubric level ranges to students. This feature enhances consistency and reduces ambiguity.

Figure: Define the scoring levels and criteria when creating or editing a rubric. Adjust custom points by entering values in the corresponding fields under each level column.

Instructor Guided Training – Reminder

If you have not done so already, please feel free to access our D2L guided instructor training course by clicking the link with the D2L moose on your homepage. At first this training looks barren with only a few items, but as you complete each module a new one will open up! This training goes through the basics of D2L all the way through more advanced tools and is available to all instructors of the college. You will also be entered to win some D2L branded prizes such as a Morris the Moose plushie, travel pillows, and tumbler cups!

Figure: The instructor guided training link.

D2L February 2025 Updates
D2L February 2025 Updates avatar

D2L February Updates

Brightspace Editor – Updated Accessibility Checker icon | Updated

This release updates the Accessibility Checker icon in Brightspace Editor to improve user recognition and understanding with a more universal icon.

Image: The updated accessibility checker icon in the Brightspace editor.

Quizzes – Filter Quiz Statistics by Section or Group | New

Quiz statistics now include filters for Sections or Groups, allowing instructors to analyze specific sections and groups effectively.

Image: New quiz statistic filters
Instructor Guided Training – Reminder

If you have not done so already, please feel free to access our D2L guided instructor training course by clicking the link with the D2L moose on your homepage. At first this training looks barren with only a few items, but as you complete each module a new one will open up! This training goes through the basics of D2L all the way through more advanced tools and is available to all instructors of the college. You will also be entered to win some D2L branded prizes such as a Morris the Moose plushie, travel pillows, and tumbler cups!

Figure: The instructor guided training link.

February 2025 Professional Development Opportunities
February 2025 Professional Development Opportunities avatar

Date: Wednesday February 26th, 2025

Time: 1:00 pm – 2:00 pm ET

Location: Virtual

Hour (s): 1 hour

Title: Building a Case for Co-Requisite Courses

XPAA Course #: 246

To register for this Brightspace PD and other upcoming sessions, please click on the registration link below. Complete the Wufoo form to register for PD event: https://ptcgwd.wufoo.com/forms/z16bhm3m0x2n0g4/

A link to the PD event will appear on Outlook calendar within 1 week of the scheduled PD event.

Date: Friday Feb 28th, 2025

Time: 10:00 am – 12:00 noon ET

Location: Virtual

Hour(s): 2 hours

Title of Course: Instructor Essentials

XPDE Course#: 206

Description: This introductory session is geared towards users who will be working in the Learning Environment to develop courses, teach / facilitate, or support instructors who use Brightspace. Administrative, Help Desk, and Technical Support staff are also encouraged to attend to gain a better understanding of how different users will be utilizing the tools.

To register for this Brightspace PD and other upcoming sessions, please click on the registration link below. Complete the Wufoo form to register for PD event: https://ptcgwd.wufoo.com/forms/zu7eaz1019jz6l/

A link to the PD event will appear on Outlook calendar within 1 week of the scheduled PD event.

D2L January 2025 Updates
D2L January 2025 Updates avatar

D2L January Updates

Consistent Evaluation – Assignment and Discussion evaluations now synchronized with Grade Book | Updated

The individual scores and feedback from Assignment and Discussion grade items are now synchronized with the grade book using the Update button regardless of whether a change was made. The Update button in Assignments and Discussions evaluations is always available to update, even when no changes were made. This feature also enables instructors to verify that the information between the grade book and the Assignment or Discussion tool is properly synchronized.

Previously, In Brightspace, when an instructor evaluated an assignment, discussion, or quiz using a rubric and saved it as a draft, then added feedback directly in the grade book and saved, the feedback did not sync back to the evaluation page when the instructor clicked Update.

Rubrics – Streamline grading with minimum or maximum score for ungraded rubric criteria | New

This feature updates the instructor workflow of evaluating a rubric and providing feedback to students. Now, instructors can quickly assess all ungraded Rubric criteria and then go back through to add feedback where necessary. To provide a more streamlined experience for instructors using analytical type rubrics for assessments in the Consistent Evaluation experience for assignments, discussions, and written response quiz questions, the instructor can automatically set ungraded levels to a minimum or maximum value.

From a drop-down beside the rubric name in each assessment pop-out, or from a context menu in Consistent Evaluation, there are two options:

Set Ungraded to [lowest rubric level name]: where all ungraded levels within this rubric are set to the minimum value using the bottom level of the rubric.

Set Ungraded to [top rubric level name]: where all ungraded levels within this rubric are set to the maximum value using the top level of the rubric.

Image: Context Menu offering new minimum or maximum score for ungraded rubric criteria
Instructor Guided Training – Reminder

If you have not done so already, please feel free to access our D2L guided instructor training course by clicking the link with the D2L moose on your homepage. At first this training looks barren with only a few items, but as you complete each module a new one will open up! This training goes through the basics of D2L all the way through more advanced tools and is available to all instructors of the college. You will also be entered to win some D2L branded prizes such as a Morris the Moose plushie, travel pillows, and tumbler cups!

Figure: The instructor guided training link.

D2L November 2024 Updates
D2L November 2024 Updates avatar

D2L November 2024 Updates

Instructor Guided Training – Reminder

If you have not done so already, please feel free to access our D2L guided instructor training course by clicking the link with the D2L moose on your homepage. At first this training looks barren with only a few items, but as you complete each module a new one will open up! This training goes through the basics of D2L all the way through more advanced tools and is available to all instructors of the college. You will also be entered to win some D2L branded prizes such as a Morris the Moose plushie, travel pillows, and tumbler cups!

Figure: The instructor guided training link.
Groups – Restore groups and categories | Updated

The recycle bin feature has been added to the Groups tool, allowing for restoration of deleted groups and group categories. Previously, all group deletions were final and unrecoverable.

Image: Recycle Bin in manage groups area.


Image: Deleted group inside of the recycle bin, able to be restored.

PTC Online Proctoring FAQ
PTC Online Proctoring FAQ avatar

Online Proctoring & You!

What Proctoring Services does PTC offer for Online Courses?

PTC Has two distinct online proctoring services in addition to offering in-person proctoring at any county campus testing center: Honorlock & Respondus Lockdown Browser

Which one should I use for my course?

Each proctoring service is unique in which class modalities they should be used for and should never be used on the same exam at the same time.

Honorlock is to be used in Online-only courses for the purpose of fulfilling the federal requirements for PTC to properly identify our distance education students – the ability to help flag cheating is just a welcome bonus!
Edit, August 13th, 2025: Starting Fall 2025 it will also be a requirement that our fully online courses proctor their Syllabus quiz to identify our online students before add-drop periods end!

On the other hand, Respondus Lockdown Browser is to be used for in-person synchronous testing at a PTC computer lab, and it’s main focus is to “lockdown” the student browser to prevent cheating.

How do I activate/deactivate an exam in my course with one of these proctoring services?

The dashboards for both programs are in a different area but both serve the same purpose – making enabling/disabling exams fast and easy. For Honorlock you will need to select “More” on your course’s navigation bar and then “Honorlock” which will pull up a dashboard of all exams in your course. From there, you may select “Enable” next to any exam you’d like to require Honorlock, or check results & settings for exams already enabled.


For Respondus Lockdown Browser you can access the “Lockdown Browser” tab on the “Quizzes” area in D2L. It will also populate with a list of tests you can freely activate/deactivate. Please note that this area contains an option for “Require Respondus Monitor” which should not be used – Respondus Monitor is a separate product that PTC does not have.

How long before the test do I have to enable proctoring services?

These services can be enabled at any time before the test! Best practice is to do a sweep of your courses and enable/disable the tests in your needed service at the start of the semester – you’ll never need to touch them for the rest of that course! Keep an eye out for our “Start of Semester” checklists, there will be a reminder in them to do just that!

I have a student that is not comfortable being recorded remotely via Honorlock, what do I do?

Privacy is very important to us and we will never require a student to consent to recording if they are not comfortable with it. If a student does not want to be remotely proctored, they may be sent to the testing center at any county campus. Staff onsite will input a code for the student that will then disable Honorlock, trading the online proctoring for an in-person proctoring session there.

I have a test in Respondus that a student cannot attend and will need to makeup in a testing center; how do I ensure they can enter the test?

You can allow students to enter a respondus test without respondus using Special Access in D2L.  Simply check the “Not Required to Take this Quiz” under “Lockdown Browser” in the special access menu. Remember to give the testing center your test password, they will need it!

I saw a weird password on my test after enabling in Honorlock, should I change it or give it to my students?

NO! The passwords that have “HL_NO_EDIT_####” Schema are set by Honorlock automatically. Students should never be asked for a password for an exam that is set up and taken properly, changing the password or giving it out can make the test completely inaccessible to students or allow them to bypass proctoring all together! Honorlock will automatically insert the password for the student without them even knowing!

My students say Honorlock is asking them for a password, what do I do?

Firstly, check to ensure that Honorlock has been enabled on your exam. Honorlock uses the password it generates to associate with the quiz it is connected to, if it is not enabled then Honorlock doesn’t know which password to use!

If your quiz is enabled in Honorlock, it is very likely a student-side issue with not having the required extension installed. If a student starts an exam without Honorlock installed – it will prompt them to install it and provide them with a password box. Once installed, the student may begin the exam!

A student says Honorlock is not acting properly for them, what now?

Honorlock provides 24/7/365 US-Based customer service for both students and instructors alike! Your student may click the “Chat Bubble” at the bottom of the screen during their exam at any time, enter their information, and be connected with a support agent within minutes to receive real-time support for any technical issues once an exam starts.

A student is using a device that is no longer supported by Honorlock, how can they complete their exam?

Honorlock supports most any modern device but older Chromebooks may restrict access to updating Google Chrome to a supported version. In that case, the student will need to take the exam at any county campus testing center. Please note that cellphones, even ones using Google Chrome, cannot be used for Honorlock exams.

Where can I get more information about D2L and Online Proctoring?

You can get additional D2L training by clicking Morris the Moose on your D2L homescreen! This will take you to our guided online instructor training which includes online proctoring and many more topics regarding D2L! Complete it and submit the wufoo form at the end to be entered to win D2L-Branded prizes!